Erin Penoyer 

• Licensed RE Salesperson
• licensed as Erin Penoyer-Gerbino

A friend recommended that I contact Erin Penoyer for my apartment search, and I am so glad that I did! I had specific requests for what I wanted in my new home, and Erin filtered through several listings and presented an apartment that exceeded my expectations. I decided to make an offer quite fast, and I was impressed that she was able to quickly deliver detailed information about the apartment, building, and neighborhood to support my decision. I appreciated her timely responsiveness and her guidance from submitting the offer through closing. Erin’s calm, confident approach and preparedness made the home buying process stress-free. I love my new home and highly recommend Erin as your broker.

We had a wonderful experience working with Erin Penoyer, who brokered the rental of a garden apartment in our home. Erin gave excellent advice about the renovations and upgrades that were needed, and recommended vendors and service companies that we were very pleased with. She always responded immediately whenever we had a question, kept us informed about the showings, and executed all necessary paperwork in a timely manner. Erin is a pleasure to work with: professional, personable, helpful, efficient and knowledgeable about the real estate market. We will definitely call upon Erin again if the apartment becomes vacant in the future, and recommend her to anyone who is seeking a broker.

Erin was instrumental as our broker. Being first-time buyers, we had so many questions and Erin, with limitless patience and calmness, guided us through the whole process. We are eternally grateful to her and would strongly recommend her as your broker.

We worked with Erin for over a year to find our new home. She remained diligent and steadfast in her search and it paid off. Buying a home in NYC is no small feat - so having a committed and dedicated partner like Erin made all the difference in our success - she was truly my partner in this process. Her patience, her expertise and her positive attitude made the process more easeful. Along the way - she also helped me to learn about the intricacies of the home-buying (particularly for buying a co-op) process. Erin is also very organized and communicative. If you want a knowledgeable, intelligent, thoughtful broker - who will truly get to know you and your needs - I highly recommend working with Erin as your broker.

Erin Penoyer was our broker in 2019. I was not an enthusiastic first time homebuyer and Erin helped make the process so much easier and more comfortable. From the moment we met her we appreciated her professionalism, her warmth, and her consistent follow up. We felt like she really learned what was important to us and helped steer us in the right direction and counsel us along the way. In the past few years whenever we hear of someone who is looking to buy or sell we always recommend Erin (whether or not they ask for our recommendation ??).