Skip to main content
Corcoran is a Real Estate Company, Logo
  • Shelter Island, NY
Enter a location, address, ZIP or property ID
  • Shelter Island, NY
  • Sort By
    • Recommended
    • Newest
    • Price low to high
    • Price high to low
    • Most square feet
    • Open houses
    • Coming Soon

There are 37 homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY

PRESENTED BY CORCORAN GROUP
  • 1/25
    Shelter Island

    9 Crescent Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    contemporary
    • 3 BD
    • 2 BA
    • 1 HB
    • 2,373 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $1,795,000
  • 1/32
    Shelter Island

    106 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    cape
    • 4 BD
    • 4 BA
    • 2,417 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $2,695,000
  • Shelter Island

    101 South Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    ranch
    • 2 BD
    • 1 BA
    • 1,008 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $799,000
  • new
    Finding your perfect home is about to get a whole lot easier.
    Enter your target location, price range, and preferred amenities, and Corcoran.com’s smart search will find your just-right matches.
  • Trending
    1/4
    Shelter Island

    29D Osprey Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    bungalow
    • 2 BD
    • 2 BA
    • 1,826 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $825,000
  • Trending
    1/34
    Shelter Island

    24 Harbor Lane, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    colonial
    • 4 BD
    • 4 BA
    • 1 HB
    • 3,736 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $6,995,000
  • 1/13
    Shelter island

    65 North Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    ranch
    • 3 BD
    • 3 BA
    • 1,718 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $1,195,000
  • Trending
    1/19
    Shelter Island

    52 South Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    farm/farmhouse
    • 4 BD
    • 3 BA
    • 2,200 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $3,595,000
  • Trending
    1/20
    Shelter Island

    62 Country Club Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    other
    • 2 BD
    • 2 BA
    • 2,158 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $1,495,000
  • 1/25
    Shelter Island

    70 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    farm/farmhouse
    • 5 BD
    • 3 BA
    • 2,000 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $1,950,000
  • 1/35
    Shelter Island

    79 North Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    english/country
    • 8 BD
    • 6 BA
    • 3 HB
    • 8,000 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $8,750,000
  • 1/6
    Shelter Island

    13 Winthrop Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965

    Residential
    • 1 BD
    • 1 BA
    • 650 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $595,000
  • 1/34
    Shelter Island

    5 East Brander Parkway, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    colonial
    • 5 BD
    • 6 BA
    • 4,495 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $7,495,000
  • 1/34
    Shelter Island Heights

    20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

    victorian
    • 7 BD
    • 5 BA
    • 4,124 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $4,995,000
  • Trending
    1/14
    Shelter Island

    11F Petticoat Lane, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    ranch
    • 4 BD
    • 2 BA
    • 1,900 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $1,395,000
  • 1/34
    Shelter Island

    156 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    colonial
    • 4 BD
    • 2 BA
    • 2 HB
    • 3,518 Sq. Ft.
    • On-Site Open House
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $3,475,000
  • 1/10
    Shelter Island

    8 Tim's Trail, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    contemporary
    • 4 BD
    • 4 BA
    • 1 HB
    • 3,689 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $1,995,000
  • 1/35
    Shelter Island

    8 Cove Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    contemporary
    • 4 BD
    • 5 BA
    • 3,200 Sq. Ft.
    Building presented by Corcoran
    Courtesy of Corcoran
    $5,750,000
  • 1/7
    Dering Harbor

    31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964

    Land
      Building presented by Corcoran
      Courtesy of Corcoran
      $2,895,000
    • 1/31
      Shelter Island

      7 Lake Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

      raised-ranch
      • 5 BD
      • 4 BA
      • 1 HB
      • 3,020 Sq. Ft.
      Building presented by Corcoran
      Courtesy of Corcoran
      $2,950,000
    • 1/20
      Shelter Island

      16 Little Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

      ranch
      • 3 BD
      • 2 BA
      • 2,200 Sq. Ft.
      Building presented by Corcoran
      Courtesy of Corcoran
      $5,900,000
    • 1/35
      Shelter Island Heights

      8 Hilo Drive, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964

      modern
      • 4 BD
      • 5 BA
      • 1 HB
      • 3,985 Sq. Ft.
      Building presented by Corcoran
      Courtesy of Corcoran
      $3,950,000
    • 1/44
      Shelter Island

      90 Peconic Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964

      Single Family
      • 5 BD
      • 3 BA
      • 1 HB
      • 3,325 Sq. Ft.
      Courtesy of Susan C CincottaLI #811480
      $5,700,000
    • New | Apr 03
      1/39
      Shelter Island

      27 Country Club Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

      Single Family
      • 3 BD
      • 2 BA
      • 3,170 Sq. Ft.
      Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl RltyLI #842082
      $1,990,000
    • 1/39
      Shelter Island Heights

      15A / 15 & 13 S Menantic Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964

      Single Family
      • 9 BD
      • 4 BA
      • 2 HB
      • 3,944 Sq. Ft.
      • Virtual Tour
      Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl RltyLI #842673
      $9,955,000
    • 1/34
      Shelter Island Heights

      31 Grand Ave and 20 Spring Garden Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

      Single Family
      • 6 BD
      • 4 BA
      • 1 HB
      • 2,640 Sq. Ft.
      Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl RltyLI #829868
      $3,200,000
    • Reduced price
      1/36
      Shelter Island

      5 Bay Shore Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

      Single Family
      • 3 BD
      • 2 BA
      • 1,500 Sq. Ft.
      Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl RltyLI #L3590276
      $2,990,000
    • 1/31
      Shelter Island

      47L S Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

      Single Family
      • 4 BD
      • 3 BA
      • 1 HB
      • 3,800 Sq. Ft.
      • Virtual Tour
      Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl RltyLI #838795
      $9,900,000
    • Reduced price
      1/25
      Shelter Island

      9 & 7 Westmoreland Dr., Shelter Island, NY 11964

      Single Family
      • 6 BD
      • 4 BA
      • 1 HB
      • 4,957 Sq. Ft.
      • Virtual Tour
      Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl RltyLI #L3567654
      $7,950,000
    • 1/21
      Shelter Island Heights

      25 W Neck Road, 4, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964

      Commercial
        Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl RltyLI #836104
        $2,500,000
      • 1/43
        Shelter Island

        61 Gardiners Bay Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

        Single Family
        • 6 BD
        • 4 BA
        • 4,949 Sq. Ft.
        Courtesy of Signature Premier PropertiesLI #834105
        $2,750,000
      • 1/12
        Shelter Island

        10 Sunshine Road, B, Shelter Island, NY 11964

        Single Family
        • 4 BD
        • 4 BA
        • 1 HB
        • 5,300 Sq. Ft.
        Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real EstateLI #L3592958
        $2,795,000
      • In contract
        1/7
        Shelter Island

        9 West Neck Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965

        Land
          Building presented by Corcoran
          Courtesy of Corcoran
          $1,050,000
        • In contract
          1/6
          Shelter Island

          6 Dering Woods Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

          Land
            Building presented by Corcoran
            Courtesy of Corcoran
            $1,100,000
          • In contract
            1/39
            Shelter Island

            5 Wade Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

            Single Family
            • 3 BD
            • 3 BA
            • 1,854 Sq. Ft.
            Courtesy of Signature Premier PropertiesLI #825119
            $1,499,000
          • In contract
            Reduced price
            1/17
            Shelter Island

            8 Tims Trail, Shelter Island, NY 11964

            Single Family
            • 4 BD
            • 4 BA
            • 1 HB
            • 3,689 Sq. Ft.
            Courtesy of Homecoin ComLI #801164
            $1,799,000
          • In contract
            Reduced price
            1/19
            Shelter Island

            1 Rebel Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

            Single Family
            • 2 BD
            • 2 BA
            • 1,472 Sq. Ft.
            Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl RltyLI #L3563528
            $1,185,000
          • 1/34
            Shelter Island

            Shelter Island, NY 11964

            modern
            • 5 BD
            • 6 BA
            • 2 HB
            • 5,800 Sq. Ft.
            • Virtual Tour
            Building presented by Corcoran
            Courtesy of Corcoran
            $13,250,000
          BESbswy